Elgin Deanery
St Andrews
(Kilmalemnoc)
Parish Church: OS Ref: NGR NJ 249627 H.E.S. No: NJ26SW 24 Dedication: Originally St Moluag of Lismore, then St Andrew the Apostle.
Associated Chapels: Inchbroom {NGR NJ 254665}; Foresterseat {NGR NJ 253629}.
There has been much confusion amongst historians regarding the name of this church, not least because it was united with the parish of Lhanbryde in 1782, after which, the building at St Andrews was allowed to fall into ruin. The new name of the parish became "St Andrews - Lhanbryde" but, for some, this has suggested that there had only ever been one parish - that this parish was located at Lhanbryde, and that it had been dedicated to St Andrew the Apostle. However, the truth of the matter is that St Andrews existed as a separate parish for many hundreds of years. Also, the problem was further exacerbated by the fact that St Andrews was often referred to as the church of Kilmalemnoc.1
The ancient name of the church - Kilmalemnoc (Kil-mo-Lemnoc) - reveals the great antiquity of the site. At some later date, as often happened in Scotland, the dedication of the church became 'St Andrews', in-line with a trend to replace the names of the very first missionaries with more 'biblical' names. Indeed, the traditions of the Early Church did not include the act of dedicating churches at all - in those days they just came to bear the name of some early saint by popular usage. In the case we have before us, the name Kilmalemnoc contains the name of that early saint. He is believed to be none other than the famous Saint Moluag, Bishop of Lismore, who is often found named in the older texts as Lugaidh (pronounced 'Lua'), Luag or Lemnoc.2
The church, which was later dedicated to St Andrew, appears to be identical with "the chapel of St Andrew" granted by William the Lion, along with its mother church of Elgin, to Richard, bishop of Moray, 1187 x 89.3
At the beginning of the fourteenth century, the church was served by a chaplain maintained by the Vicar of Elgin, but subsequent to this the church appears to have attained parochial status, its cure becoming a vicarage perpetual, while the parsonage remained with the bishops of Moray. It is possible that the parish boundaries corresponded with the boundaries of the lands of the barony of Kilmalemnock. The lands of the barony of included St Andrews Kirktown
A number of authors 5 have suggested that the original church in this parish was at Foresterseat, however, there does not seem to be any evidence to support this. There certainly was a chapel at or beside the House of Foresterseat (vide infra), which is not really surprising since the River Lossie could prove impassable to the parishioners, preventing them from attending their parish church. This matter was a major concern throughout the history of the parish of St Andrews. Within the minutes of both the parish council and meetings of the local presbytery (Elgin), there is a considerable body of evidence which reflects the difficulties that were experienced, and the substantial expense that was necessitated, to maintain a river-crossing. (We have chosen to accomodate some of this information at the end of this web-page.)
The author, Mr Andrew Jervise, insisted that St Andrews, on the west bank of the River Lossie, was the original location of the ancient church which bore St Moluag's name, but, again, there is little or no evidence to support this. However, since no archaeological remains of an Early Church foundation have been found in the vicinity of the old Parish Church, there is the possibility that the first church was built elsewhere - perhaps at Foresterseat. Cosmo Innes suggested that "it was an appartment within the Castle [of Foresterseat] before it was demolished." 6
Sadly, Cramond tells us that there once was "an old font in the churchyard which had been broken in three places," but, in 1899, he noted that "there was no trace of it." 7 This font would, perhaps, have provided important dating evidence for the church and there is the possibility that it is still somewhere nearby.
Although it has often been said that St Andrews was a mensal church, some writers have contested this, saying that there is no evidence to support the idea. However, William Cramond gave the following:
In the Minutes of the Presbytery of Elgin we find it noted that, in 1749, "the King is patron and titular of St Andrews [parish]." It would appear that the King had passed the parish into the hands of the Earl of Murray. (After the Second Reformation, the Earls of Moray were 'Stuarts' and were thus closely related to the Royal Family). Cramond's quotation given above would seem to settle the matter in favour of St Andrews having being a mensal church.
Name | OS Grid Ref. | Extent | Comment |
---|---|---|---|
Barflathills | NJ 230636 | 4 auchten parts. | Shown on early OS Maps. |
Over Barflathills | NJ | 1 auchten part. | |
Haugh of Barflathills | NJ | 1 auchten part. | |
St Andrews Kirktown | NJ 248629 | (Kirkhill) | |
Frosterseat | NJ 253629 | Foresterseat | |
Dumkempty | NJ 232614 | Dunkinty | |
Petgony | NJ 240653 | Pitgaveny | |
Cottis | NJ 275666/253637 | Cotts or Easter Calcots | |
Scotstonhill9 | NJ 262628 | (Possibly part of Foresterseat) | |
Certain information above from Ross (2003).10 Additional information, and Locations by David at Cushnieent. |
After the 'Second Reformation' (1560), the parish of St Andrews underwent a number of 're-organisations'. The fact that substantial parts of the parish lay on the opposite side of the River Lossie from the parish church was always a considerable inconvenience. The Presbytery of Elgin, of which St Andrews formed a part, attempted to re-arrange matters in order to solve the geographical, and other, problems.
c.1574 the parish was united with Elgin.
c.1615 the parish was united with that of Ogston, but was separated again in 1625.
1642 the parish was united again with Ogston, but disjoined on 28 July, 1647, (ratified in Parliament, 10 June, 1648).
1781-82 the parish was finally united with Lhanbryde.
1782 There exists a letter, dated 24th February, 1782, and addressed to William Rose, factor to Lord Fife at Montcoffer.11 The letter, which, from the wording, may be assumed to have been written by the Minister of St Andrews, runs as follows:-
Clearly, the whole idea of the annexation was very contentious to say the least!
However, the process went ahead and the two parishes were amalgamated. In 1796, a new church building was erected mid-way between the two old parish churches. The two old parish church buildings were left to fall into ruins.
c.1380. Bishop Alexander Bur (1362-1397) made a protest against the Earl of Moray and the burgesses of Elgin anent the use of the lands and port of Spyni, Kynnedor, and the island (Inch[broom]), they belonging to the Bishopric of Moray. He maintained that the Bishops, his predecessors, were wont to have fishers of sea fish dwelling in the town of Spyni, with their wives and families sailing from Spyni to the sea, and bringing back their boats with fishes to the said port, in the name of the Bishop of Moray.13
1426. An early occurrence of the name Kilmalemnoc is in a charter of King James I, in which he confirmed a grant by Archibald, Earl of Douglas, to his brother, James of Douglas [of Balvenie], of certain lands in the country of Moray, including all lands lying within the thanedoms in the lordship of Kylmalaman.14
1539. There exists a precept of sasine upon a charter of resignation in favour of Alexander Innes of that Ilk, of the lands of Innes, the lands of Kelmalmak, and the lands of Aberchirder, all in one barony, date 25th March, 1539.15
1543. According to the Register of the Bishopric of Moray, a charter was granted in 1543 to Alexnder Innes of that Ilk, of Eskill and Sanct Androis Kirkhill in the baronies of Birneth and Spynie.16
1553. William Innes of that Ilk became posessed of the lands and barony of Kilmalemnok; Alexander Innes posessed them in 1573; John Innes in 1578.17
Inchbroom (Isle of Spinet)
A case regarding the possession of the husband tenandry (tenandria husbandalis) of the chapel of Inch came before the Consistory Court of Moray on 23rd July, 1522, Sir David Fotheringhame, chaplain of the chapel of the Isle of Spinet, called Our Lady's Chapel, Inch, pursuer, and William Clerk, defender. Sentence was passed by Anselm Robertson, Succentor of Ross, canon and Commissary General of Moray, finding "that the chaplain and his predecessors were actual possessors of the tenandry of the Inch, and in use of feeding their beasts from the place commonly called the Thornye Bray [Thorny Brae] to the place commonly called by Taill of the Meadow, and going from the end of the meadow to the Water of Lossy, going down through the said water and by the side of the said chapel on the north-side thereof, as proper pasture annexed to said chapel."18
In 1544, William Sutherland, chaplain of the Lady's Chaplainry of Inch, commonly called Our Lady's Chapel of Inch, granted a charter, with the consent of the Bishop of Murray, in favour of Alexander Innes of that Ilk, of the lands of Inch within the regality, on payment of 57s. 4d. yearly, of Spynie.
Thomas Brebner was chaplain of Inch at least from 1571 to 1582. In the former year he granted, as Superior, a precept of clare constant for infefting Alexander Innes of that Ilk in the lands of Inch.
A charter of confirmation under the Great Seal upon the lands of Inch and Stonewalls
Foresterseat
From the south side of the churchyard straight up the banks of the Lossie to the coble staike [a stake which held the church boat fast], thence lineally westward to the end of a mearing [a strip of uncultivated ground between two corn ridges] and thence northward up the said mearing by severall thorn bushes to the highway leading to the church to the foord of the water of Lossie and thence to the churchyard.20
We present here a somewhat extended series of notes, which other writers might have chosen to omit. However, we believe that they provide such a fascinating 'snap-shot' of the parish of St Andrews, and its troubles, in the period immediately prior to its amalgamation with the Parish of Lhanbryde, that the reader will find themself almost sharing the trials and tribulations of the Session and Minister! It is quite a rare 'cameo' of eighteenth century church life.
As has already been noted, throughout its history, the Parish of St Andrews suffered from its division into two parts by the River Lossie. With the advent of better record keeping in the form of the minutes of various Church bodies such as the Presbytery of Elgin, the Parish itself and even the Synod of Moray, we regularly find entries regarding the provision of a river-crossing to allow parishioners better access to Sunday services. Most importantly, we should recognise that these valuable insights reveal a real problem that had faced the parish for many years!
What follows here is a selection of entries from the various 'sources', the majority of which relate to the provision of a crossing of the River Lossie. From these entries, it would seem that there had been first a fording point near where the present footbridge is located, at
We should also bear in mind that the crossing was not only of importance to the parishioners. For generations, travellers heading to and from Elgin used the route provided by the King's Highway - leaving Elgin by the bridge over the Tyock Burn
1650 - 20th June - The Session of Elgin supplicates that, "Linkwoodes might rather be annexed to Elgin [parish] than kept at Sanct Andrewes seeing the water of Locye [Lossie] is interjected twixt them and ther paroch kirk wheras nothing may hinder them repaireing to Elgin at anie tyme." [Linkwoodes = 'Linkwood' [
1708 - 15th June - The Session of St Andrews, having no beddell nor officer at present, (…) Eddison, who was the last having commited that unnatural act of self murder, hanged himself in the bel's tow.21
1708 - the same day, the Session determined the duties of the new Beadle /Church Officer.
"You are to attend and go about the affairs of this Session when called, for which you are to receive 4lbs Scots yearly, two pair of shoes with 4s. Scots from each married couple [each wedding] and 2s. of each baptism with a penny every Sabbath and bol. bear in the east sid of the water and dinner each Sabbath in the minister's house as use was, and the Session appoints a spaid [spade] for the use of the church and casting of graves and you to maintain the same afterwards and to gate [get] 6s. 8d. [half a mark] for the grave's casting and 3s. 4d. [quarter of a mark] for the hand bell's carriage, to all of which he agreed and promited punctuall obedience and received the kie [key] of the church from the minister."22
1726 - 18th August - The church had been thatched with turves of heather but required re-thatching £28 Scots. It had a south door, a north door and a big door [west door?], also eight windows.
1726 - 7th September - As the winter was now approaching and the old boat could not conveniently serve for carrying the parishioners on the other side of Lossie over to and from the church on the Lord's Day, the session agree that a boat be made at Garmouth, the price thereof £24 Scots.
1727 - 7th March - Received for the old boat £2.
1727 - 6th August - The church of St Andrews, with all the seats therein, was burnt to ashes by a boy shooting doves sitting thereon, and the next day being the Lord's Day, the minister preached in the churchyard, and desired the congregation to meet next Lord's Day at the kiln [milne/mill?] of Pitgaveny.
1727 - 30th August - It is represented that since last presbytery, the church of St Andrews, by some accident or other, is burnt to ashes, as also, that there is no manse for the minister of that parish, notwithstanding of a decreet of presbyterie for the building of it.
1731 - 23rd November - The heritors assure the presbytery the church will be roofed next summer, and its not being done before was occasioned by the couples being thrown down by a strong wind.
1731 - 24th November - The elders said the … boat which the Session had bought some years ago was broken.
1733 - 12th July - The Session appointed the boat to be mended.
1734 - Paid for materials for mending the boat and workmanship, £4 16s.
1737 - 8th March - Paid Alexander Shearer for the boat £3.
1737 - 9th August - Paid Alexander Shearer for making the intack safe for passage 12s.
1738 - 9th February - Paid Alexander Shearer for managing the boat £3.
1738 - 9th July - The Session, considering they wanted a boat in Lossie that in case of a speat [spate/flood] the people on the other side could not attend worship, appointed the minister and Gilbert Brander to buy one [the minister at the time was John Paterson (1731-78)].
1738 - 4th August - Paid for a boat £7 4s.
1739 - 26th June - The manse of St Andrews is now built. The minister has now the legal grass [glebe].The church is in good repair and well divided with seats. The churchyard wants dykes.
1739 - 5th August - To Robert Ross for managing the boat the time of the Sacrament, the water being in speat 18s. For a lock to secure the boat 12s. The minister has bought a new boat for £18 Scots.
1740 - 18th June - From the Minutes of the Presbytery of Elgin.
Visitation to St Andrews. The Presbytery appoint a schoolhouse and a chamber for the master to be built 33 feet long (20 for the school and 13 for the chamber), walls 7 feet high, with a chimney in the chamber, with three windows in the school and one in the chamber, with doors and locks and a partition 'twixt the school and the chamber, and two tables and four forms for the school, with a divet thatch [divet = 'divot' or 'turf']. To be built at the west end of the town of Kirkhill.23
Master's salary to be 100 marks, comprising:
7 bols bere @ £5 | £35 |
parishioners to find | £31 13s. 4d. |
Total = | £66 13s. 4d. (or 100 marks) |
The cost of the building was projected to be:
Winning of stones, lime and clay. | £37 10s. |
Workmanship, incl. barrowman | £108 |
The parish to provide the materials. | |
Wrights | £75 6s. 8d. |
21 trees for 7 couples | £12 12s. 0d. |
Partition lath & backs | £3 0s. 0d. |
Four windows | £8 0s. 0d. |
Two tables & 4 forms | £8 0s. 0d. |
5000 divets of turf | £13 6s. 8d. |
Total = | £268 16s. Scots (£22 8s. Sterling) [i.e. £1 Sterling = £12 Scots] |
1741 - 5th February - The minister has caused mend the boat which was much broken by the ice last speat.
1741 - 25th June - Paid for five pints of tar to the boat and the man's wages.
1743 - 3rd July - Paid for four deals for mending the boat 12s.
1745 - Price of the boat £11 16s. Paid for a lock to the boat.
1746 - 13th January - For mending the boat £5 17s.
1747 - 5th January - Expended £4 6s. Scots for the boat.
1748 - 8th August - Price of the old boat £2 14s. Scots.
1750 - 2nd July - George Baird having undertaken to build a bridge of timber over the water of Lossie and the minister having found the people would contribute £60 Scots thereto, the Session, knowing what a conveniency it would prove for the people in attending the worship of God and also for the whole countrie in passing about their business and that it would afterwards ease the Session of the expense of a boat, approved of the agreement with George Baird, who obliges himself that it shall neither be carried away by wind or water for ten years.
1751 - 7th January - Collected for the bridge £69 10s. Expense of building the bridge £49 15s. (timber £42; lime, tar and fog £3 6s.; iron and nails £34 6s. etc.) The balance paid out of the box.
1752 - 18th June - The old boat sold for 6s. sterling.
1753 - 2nd July - The Session agree to pitch the bridge to make it more durable, cost £7 0s. 2d.
1757 13th June - As the bridge had fallen the timber was sold by roup at near £8 Scots. So much of the revels was kept as might be of use for another bridge. The iron came of £14 16s. The Session, considering how great a conveniency the bridge was to this parish, and having experience of the inconvenience of the form of it as the timber rotted in the bulwark, thought a bridge with a middle pillar of hewnstone would be more secure and therefor desired the minister to employ proper persons to try if there was a good foundation and, if so, to get a middle pillar built this summer and if that took effect to petition the presbytrie for a collection within their bounds to enable them to build a more secure bridge as it is now well known how great a conveniency it was for the whole countrie when the water was in spate.
1758 - 6th February - For mending the boat £13 14s.
An agreement is made with Hugh Grant, mason in Elgin, for building a bridge with a middle pillar for twelve guineas. The Presbytery allow collections for the bridge in their several parishes.
{Extract from the Session records of Alves.}
1758 - 16th February - Mr Watt [Minister 1753-1774] intimated to the congregation that the bridge upon the Water of Lossy opposite St Andrews had fallen down and that the kirk-session of that place not being able to rebuild the same had solicited the assistance of the neighbouring parishes and therefore he hoped that they would contribute liberally next Lord's day in order to help them forward with so necessary a work. [£5 10s. collected]
1762 - Paid for iron to secure the bridge £2.
1764 - Paid John Stewart for … a piece of plate for securing the bridge.
1765 - Paid for iron for securing the bridge £1 8s.
1768 - 18th May - Paid for timber for helping the bridge. To Archibald Ramsay for 83lb. 12oz. of iron work for the bridge £15. Two trees from Speymouth £2 16s.
1771 - Paid for six trees to the bridge £90; for tar to ditto, £11 5s.; for workmanship £3 18s.
1776 - To iron for bands to the bridge and lead for fixing them £3 12s. 6d. Hugh Grant, mason in Elgin, for re-building the bridge and providing stone and lime for the same, got 50s. Stirling.
1783 Paid £2 also £5 5s. to James Urquhart for repairing the pillars of the bridge.
1786 - Paid for new painting of the bridge, 14s.
1787 - Paid 4s. 6d. for the carriage of stones to the bridge being 18 loads for preventing the pillars being undermined.
1789 - 20th September - A great speat in Lossie cut off all communication with the church, therefore no collection.
1789 - 11th October - A speat in Lossy, equal to that of 20 September last, cut off all communications with the church on the other side of the water as well as on this.
1792 - For garron nails and buts for repairing the bridge 14s.
1792 - Paid the English Company of Garmach for wood to repair the bridge, £2 5s. 9d.
{This was the company established at Kingston of Garmouth by William Osbourne, a merchant of Hull. The company purchased and felled the whole forest of Glenmore and rafted it down the Spey. This business started in 1783.24
{From the Session records of Llhanbryde.}
1796 - 9th May - The Church of St Andrews being taken down upon Monday, May 9th 1796, there was no public worship in the parish upon the three last Sundays of May, nor upon the four Sundays of the month of June. The schoolhouse being roofed in, the congregation were assembled there upon 3rd July.
1. The name Kilmalemnoc has many variations - Kilmalemak, Kelmalmak, Kilmolymok. Return to Text
2. In his thesis, Dr Ross becomes a little inventive here. Quoting [Watson, CPNS, 327-328], he suggests that the original saint whose name the church bore "was either Mo-Lomma or Lomnán." Perhaps he would have been wise to note Watson's own comment, that "the commemoration is very doubtful." Return to Text
3. REM II., no. 6, p. 6; no. 42, p. 37. Return to Text
4. Cramond (1900), p. 65. Return to Text
5. Jervaise (1875), p. 270; Mackinlay (1914), p. 505; Shaw (1775), II, p. 93. Return to Text
6. Cramond (1900), p. 65. Return to Text
7. Cramond (1900), p. 101. Return to Text
8. Cramond (1900), p. 105. Return to Text
9. Shaw(1775), II, p. 93. Shaw added this property as part of the Barony but it is seldom so included in other sources. It may have been considered part of Foresterseat. Return to Text
10. Ross (2003), I., p. 66-67.Return to Text
11. Montcoffer House was a property of the Earl of Fife 5km south of Banff
12. Cramond (1900), p. 106. Return to Text
13. Cramond (1900), p. 103-104. Return to Text
14. Cramond (1900), p. 65. Return to Text
15. Cramond (1900), p. 65. Return to Text
16. Cramond (1900), p. 65; REM, no. 368, p. 404. Return to Text
17. Cramond (1900), p. 65. Return to Text
18. Cramond (1900), p. 103-104. Return to Text
19. Cramond (1900), p. 104. Return to Text
20. Cramond (1900), p. 75. Return to Text
21. Cramond (1900), p. 77. Return to Text
22. Cramond (1900), p. 77. Return to Text
23. Cramond (1900), p. 80-81. Return to Text
Cramond, W. (1900) The Church of Lhanbryd and the Church of St Andrews, Elgin: Courant & Courier Ofice. (Aberdeen University Library bound with [x9(4123) Cra.])
Innes, C, (1837) Registrum Episcopatus Moraviensis: e pluribus codicibus consarcinatum circa A.D. MCCC, cum continuatione diplomatum recentiorum usque ad A.D. MDCXXIII, Edinburgh: for the Bannatyne Club. [REM] https://digital.nls.uk/publications-by-scottish-clubs/archive/81605180 (accessed 02/06/2023)
Jervise, A. (1875) Epitaphs & Inscriptions from Burial Grounds in the North-East of Scotland, Vol. 1, Edinburgh: Edmonston and Douglas. https://archive.org/details/epitaphsinscript00jerv/page/n7/mode/2up (accessed 31/05/2023)
Mackinlay, J.M. (1914) Ancient Church Dedications in Scotland, Vol. 2: Non-Scriptural Dedications, Edinburgh: David Douglas. https://archive.org/details/churchdedication02mackuoft/page/n5/mode/2up (accessed 31/05/2023)
Matheson, D. (1905) The Place Names of Elginshire, Stirling: Eneas Mackay. https://archive.org/details/placenamesofelgi00mathuoft (accessed 31/05/2023)
Omand, D. (1976) The Moray Book, Edinburgh: P. Harris.
Paul, James Balfour (1882) The Register of the Great Seal of Scotland, 1424-1513, Edinburgh: H.M. Register House. [RMS, II] https://archive.org/details/registrummagnisi02scot/page/n5/mode/2up (accessed 07/06/2023)
Ross, A.D. (2003) The Province of Moray, c.1000-1230, unpublished PhD thesis presented to Aberdeen University, 2 vols.
Shaw, L. (1775) The History of the Province of Moray, Enlarged and brought down to the Present Times by J.F.S. Gordon (1882), Glasgow: Hamilton Adams, & Co., 3 vols. [Shaw]
Watson, W.J. (1926) The History of the Celtic Place-Names of Scotla nd: being the Rhind lectures on archaeology (expanded) delivered in 1916, Edinburgh: Royal Celtic Society, reprinted 1993 at Edinburgh: Birlinn. [CPNS] https://archive.org/details/historyofcelticp0000unse/page/n5/mode/2up (accessed 05/06/2023)
e-mail: admin@cushnieent.com
© 2023 Cushnie Enterprises